Book Review: For Now and Forever by Sophie Love

Emily Mitchell, 35, living and working in New York City, has struggled through a string of failed relationships. When her boyfriend of 7 years takes her out for their long-awaited anniversary dinner, Emily is sure that this time will be different, that this time she will finally get the ring.

When he gives her a small bottle of perfume instead, Emily knows the time has come to break up with him–and for her entire life to have a fresh start.

Reeling from her unsatisfying, high-pressure life, Emily decides she needs a change. She decides on a whim to drive to her father’s abandoned home on the coast of Maine, a sprawling, historic house where she’d spent magical summers as a child. But the house, long-neglected, is in dire need of repair, and the winter is no time to be in Maine. Emily hasn’t been there in 20 years, when a tragic accident changed her sister’s life and shattered her family. Her parents divorced, her father disappeared, and Emily was never able to bring herself to step foot in that house again.

Now, for some reason, with her life reeling, Emily feels drawn to the only childhood place she ever knew. She plans on going just for a weekend, to clear her head. But something about the house, its numerous secrets, its memories of her father, its oceanfront allure, its small-town setting–and most of all, its gorgeous, mysterious caretaker–doesn’t want to let her leave. Can she find the answers she’s been looking for here, in the most unexpected place of all?

Can a weekend become a lifetime?


First off, this book 100% reminds me of Harvest Moon.

Girl gets tired of their life, leaves their job, moves to they’re fathers abandoned house in a little town, befriends all the townspeople and falls in love. Emily even finds a stray dog on her property that she adopts.

It’s straight out Harvest Moon minus the farming.

So that’s basically everything I loved about it. The fact that it reminded me so much of my favorite game is literally why I continued reading it.

The rest, not so much.

giphy (67)

I’m honestly not sure what happened. One minute, I was loving the book, the next it was like I was completely disconnected from everything. Every character seemed to be exactly the same. They didn’t have their own voice. All the reactions to everything was so unrealistic and down right stupid at sometimes. Also… dah fuck was up with Emily’s father?

One thing that I noticed is that this book would’ve been so much better if it was written in first person. It was written in third person and I think that’s what caused it to fall flat for me.

It sucks because this series has quite a few more books and I have no desire to read them.


2 Stars

Until next time,



2 thoughts on “Book Review: For Now and Forever by Sophie Love

  1. Oh no, this doesn’t sound very good. It’s always sad when the book starts off right buy later it gets all out of hand and doesn’t make sense 😦

    Liked by 1 person

    1. perpetualfangirl January 6, 2018 — 12:09 am

      Somehow your comment ended up in spam and I didn’t even realize it until now!

      I’m going to start checking my spam folder every night.

      And yes! I agree, if I’m not going to like it I would much rather dislike the book right from the start.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close